The formation of field theory in the second half of 19th century was a prominent case of mathematisation processes, but also had characteristics that made it strikingly different from other such processes. Not only were Faraday's concepts not formulated in mathematical terms of his time, but there were no mathematical tools available that could easily be adjusted to those concepts. At the same time, however, both Thomson and Maxwell credited Faraday for having high mathematical qualities. In my talk, I shall analyze in detail how exactly the mathematical character of Faraday's concepts could be grasped that made an analytic approach possible in the end. The case sheds light, finally, on a rather uncommon way of relating experiment and mathematics.